Industry
Update - September 5, 2005
It is hard to stay focused on business when the
aftermath of hurricane Katrina reminds us how
fragile life is and how good most of us have it.
The challenges we face are trivial by comparison,
but nevertheless, life does go on for most of
us and there is much to talk about in manufactured
housing these days. But first ---
The Manufactured Housing Institute
(MHI) and The Federal Emergency Management
Agency (FEMA) are working together to
locate and transport immediately available single
section manufactured homes to areas affected by
hurricane Katrina. FEMA wants to purchase
hundreds if not thousands of homes that can quickly
be placed as temporary housing for those who are
now homeless as a result of the devastation.
For more information on this effort and how you
can help contact MHI at www.manufacturedhousing.org
or the direct link for FEMA information and their
exact criteria is:
FEMA
info and criteria
In other news, we are hearing and seeing so many
contradictory practices as it relates to financing
manufactured homes these days it motivated me
to ask this question of our lenders, both chattel
and real-property mortgage. Just exactly
what will it take to get interest rates and loan
conditions down to a reasonable level? Is
it shorter loan terms? Is it larger minimum
down payments in order to lessen your risk and
increase the buyer’s equity? Is it
long term leases from manufactured home rental
communities? If Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
would more readily buy your chattel loans at the
same rate they buy conventional mortgage loans
would that do it? Is mandatory escrow closing
what you need for more transparency?
As I go around the Pacific Northwest talking with
homeowners in our communities I am constantly
asked the same question and the question hasn’t
changed much over the years. Why are manufactured
home loans at such a high interest rate?
Yes, I know, its primarily about the risk and
default rate as compared to other types of loans,
but when you stop and compare we have higher interest
rates than conventional stick-built homes, cars,
boats, RV’s. most credit cards, home equity
loans, educational loans, personal unsecured lines
of credit and more. Is our collateral really
that bad compared to these other financial instruments?
No, it isn’t. It’s the process
that is bad. The homes are great but the
process for sales, delivery, installation and
customer care are so bad it’s driving down
the value of the home, discouraging new buyers
from purchasing our product and turning off most
mainstream financial institutions. For decades
this has been the “elephant in the living
room” with only people like Gub Mix and
Marty Lavin addressing this issue head-on.
When will we learn and change?
A year or two ago we were promoting the exciting
new Freddie Mac long term leasehold
program that brought lower interest rates to home
buyers when their land-lease community would sign
the Freddie Mac lease, which ran 5 years longer
than the term of the loan (up to 35 years).
It effectively gave the homeowner a real property
interest that allowed the home to be considered
real property instead of personal property.
Some community owners embraced this program while
many resisted signing the daunting 48 page lease
agreement. Well, a new complication has
arisen. As a few of these communities
with the Freddie Mac lease are selling, lenders
financing the community for the new investor are
not making the loans because Fannie Mae
(who will buy that commercial mortgage once the
sale closes) doesn’t like some of the conditions
of the lease! Imagine, long term leases
that finally gave some guarantees and stability
to land lease communities and Fannie Mae inadvertently
has created a roadblock that makes this program
appear even more controversial. Who would
have thought.
Manufactured home land-lease communities are closing
all over the country, as the land beneath them
has in some instances become more valuable than
the community itself. Newspaper articles
in Arizona, Nevada, Oregon, Washington and Florida
have reported many such incidences and in Oregon
local television stations have ran numerous stories
on this phenomenon. In some cases home builders
have offered millions of dollars more for a community
just to get the land, and once the purchase closes
they immediately start the “park closure”
process.
Homeowners have 365 days to move in Oregon and
the law does not allow for mandatory compensation
for the homeowners unless they are given between
180 and 364 days to move. A new bill, HB2389
does give homeowners up to a $10,000 tax credit
and offers incentives to community owners who
will sell the community to the residents instead
of an outside developer. It also loosens
regulations on movement of older homes when those
homes are coming from communities under closure.
It is too soon to tell how effective this legislation
will be, but it’s a good start in the right
direction.
We are torn apart by this issue. Land owners
clearly have the right to do what they want with
their land, but it’s hard not to have sympathy
for these people, many of whom are either older
and find moving extremely difficult, or those
who moved into these communities in the past six
to eight years and paid “park packages”
up to $25,000 or more that are useless to them
now. You can thank the land use planners
for not seeing this trend coming and neglecting
the high demand for developable land, forcing
developers to target occupied property for re-development
to a different use. We are keeping a close
eye on this issue and will report back to you
as things change.
I am excited to attend George Allen’s
International Networking Roundtable in
Amelia Island, Florida this week. Nearly
200 community owners and managers from around
the country attend this event and I expect to
learn a great deal about what’s going on
in our industry around the nation. I will
share the insights of the other attendees upon
my return.
Finally, don’t forget to SAVE THE
DATE! Our Oregon/Washington Manufactured
Housing Industry Summit is coming up Wednesday,
January 18, 2005 in Portland. This
will be, by far, the best and most exciting Summit
ever. You can look forward to a new format,
new presenters, and more exhibitors. For
more information and registration information
visit our website at www.cwres.com.
Thank you for taking a few minutes to read this
Industry Update. If you wish to contribute
to Katrina relief, experts suggest its best to
donate money to the Red Cross. You can contact
them at:
American Red Cross
PO Box 37243
Washington, DC 20013
(800) HELP-NOW
www.redcross.org
Greg
Harmon - President
Commonwealth Real Estate Services
E-mail: greg@cwres.com
Telephone 503.244.2300 Ext. 101