Industry
Update - October 26, 2004
There has been a lot going on these past several weeks,
so let’s get right to it. Sadly, some of it
is very unfortunate.
First, Bruce Stoyer, General Manager of the Golden West/Oakwood
plant in Albany, Oregon and a 35 year veteran of our industry
passed away suddenly October 19, 2004 due to complications
from surgery. If you knew Bruce you know what a loss
this is for our industry, much less his family. Bruce
was a great guy, a straight shooter, very smart, and possessed
exceptional vision. The products he produced and the
dedication he had were legendary. Golden West, under
Bruce’s leadership lead this industry in the 1970’s
and 80’s with innovative new designs that set the
standard for the creative, modern manufactured homes of
today. For someone to stay with the same company,
through good times and bad for that many years proves Bruce
has left shoes simply too big to fill. Our condolences
to the Stoyer family and their extended family of co-workers,
customers and business associates.
Also,
Ray Robinson, owner/founder of Ideal Trailer Sales (now
Ideal Homes) in The Dallas, Oregon passed away October 15,
2004 at age 78 from complications stemming from emergency
surgery. Ray was one of the original Oregon retailers
and was active in the formation of the original dealers
association. Always an outgoing and charismatic character,
Ray started Ideal in 1951 and the business grew into several
manufactured home communities and dealerships. Son
Gary Robinson continues to operate the original dealership
adjacent to I-84 in The Dallas. Ray and his infectious
personality will be greatly missed. Our condolences
to the Robinson family.
On a more positive note, 2004 is almost over! Honestly,
what a challenging period this has been for our industry.
Everyone, including me has an opinion as to why we continue
to experience such slow and stodgy progress but few disagree
that financing continues to control our destiny. Land
and home financing, while plentiful is not what I would
call easy. As we reported earlier, most land &
home transactions require documentation that exceeds a comparable
site-built home loan. Add to this the complications
arising from purchasing the home from one source, the land
from another and the improvements from a third and it’s
no wonder our customers find “instant housing”
much more difficult than it ought to be. Still, most
progressive manufacturers and retailers recognize this challenge
and are getting better at helping the consumer streamline
the buying process. What is interesting is that the
more expensive manufactured homes seem to be outselling
the less expensive homes 5-1. You would think that,
with competition from site builders and condo projects we
would be seeing more opportunity in the “low end”
market, but manufacturers and retailer’s alike report
the middle to high-end market is the strongest.
In the land-lease community business we continue to enjoy
two positive trends. First, repossessions continue
to decline overall, meaning that there are fewer and fewer
homes being wholesaled out to real property and away from
manufactured home communities. Don’t get me
wrong….it still happens, just not nearly as often
as it did a year or two ago. Community owners continue
to buy up these homes before lenders wholesale them out
and community owners continue to offer financing on these
homes. Second, we are slowing seeing a trend toward
more new homes moving into the communities. Chattel
financing is out there and getting a bit more competitive,
with US Bank, CU Factory Built Lending, Origen Financial,
Green Tree, Country Place (Palm Harbor) 21st Mortgage and
Vanderbilt (Clayton) all solid and viable lenders competing
for quality, transparent chattel loan business.
The
September/October 2004 issue of Modern Homes Magazine (published
by MHI) concentrates on the “Rise of the Manufactured
Home Community”, including great articles on protecting
and enhancing home values, investing in a community and
community renewal and upgrade methods. This publication,
while sometimes overly optimistic, has great articles that
help us learn what is going on around the nation in our
industry. Your state associations are members of MHI
and regularly supply them with regional news and information.
If you don’t subscribe, contact the Manufactured Housing
Institute at www.modernhomes.org
Stocks
in manufactured housing companies have been up and down
over the past years as cost cutting measures and consolidations
seem to agree with analysts and investors. There are
exceptions to this, but overall the stocks are up dramatically
from three years ago, but below 52-week highs. As
I am writing this Fleetwood is at $12.78, Champion $10.72,
Palm Harbor $15.51 and Skyline at $39.00. Oh, and
Berkshire Hathaway is at $83,950.00 a share if you want
to own a piece of Clayton/Oakwood/Golden West, Vanderbilt
& 21st Mortgage.
Finally,
one of the most interesting business developments in the
Pacific Northwest took place a few weeks ago. Mike
Wolf, longtime Sales Manager and GM at Marlette in Hermiston,
along with former Oakwood CEO Miles Standish bought controlling
interest of Kit Homebuilders West in Caldwell, Idaho.
This is an exciting development as Mike has a long and successful
track record at Marlette and knows how to build competitive
homes that consumers like. I support more independent
investment in our regional manufacturing facilities and
Kit is now well positioned to fill a niche market and be
creative where other manufacturers may have trouble changing
quickly with the marketplace. Best of luck to Mike,
Miles, Alan Snitily and the rest of the folks at Kit.
We have
never faced a more important election than the one on November
2, 2004. Regardless of your political persuasion,
please exercise your right to vote. It is the freedom
to vote and choose our leaders that makes The United States
of America the greatest country on earth.
Thank
you for taking a few moments to read this Industry Update.
Greg
Harmon - President
Commonwealth Real Estate Services
E-mail: greg@cwres.com
Telephone 503.244.2300 Ext. 101